| Manager | Years | Team | Wins | Losses | Win % |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lonnie Magargle | 2000-2001 | Colorado | 121 | 71 | .630 |
| Lucian Lesage | 1986-1987, 1986-1997 | Boston, Oakland/Montreal | 789 | 555 | .587 |
| Daryl Cooper | 1986-2001 | Baltimore | 892 | 644 | .581 |
| Ken Robinson | 1986-1999 | Cincinnati/Cleveland | 775 | 569 | .577 |
| Doug Smith | 1986-2001 | Pittsburgh | 879 | 658 | .572 |
| Martin Leathers | 1990-1993 | Los Angeles/Detroit | 210 | 174 | .547 |
| Dennis Fitzgerald | 1986-2001 | Montreal/Kansas City/San Francisco | 831 | 705 | .541 |
| Max Mortell | 1993-1997 | California/Philadelphia | 249 | 231 | .519 |
| Jeff Guthart | 1987-1989, 1994-2000 | Philadelphia, Colorado/St. Louis | 488 | 472 | .508 |
| Jay Corwith | 1986-1990 | New York(NL) | 244 | 236 | .508 |
| Steve Corby | 1986-1994 | St. Louis/New York(AL) | 438 | 426 | .507 |
| Dave Bryson | 1998-2001 | Montreal/Chicago(AL) | 194 | 191 | .504 |
| Ed Lewis | 1988-2001 | Los Angeles | 659 | 685 | .490 |
| John Hall | 1988-2001 | Boston | 657 | 687 | .489 |
| Eric Bennett | 1995-2000 | California/New York(NL)/Oakland | 270 | 307 | .470 |
| Mark Simmons | 1998-2000 | Philadelphia | 121 | 137 | .469 |
| Carroll Reese | 1991-1998, 2000-2001 | New York(NL)/Florida,Philadelphia | 411 | 484 | .459 |
| John Francis | 1995-2001 | New York(AL) | 303 | 369 | .451 |
| Don Acosta | 1999-2000 | Florida | 82 | 110 | .427 |
| Dave ???? | 1986-1986 | Philadelphia | 41 | 55 | .427 |
| Bob Glaub | 1986-1987, 1986-2001 | Chicago(NL), Milwaukee/Atlanta | 733 | 995 | .424 |
| Eric Labram | 1990-2001 | Toronto | 482 | 670 | .418 |
| Craig Bergeron | 1986-2001 | Houston | 552 | 984 | .359 |