-> Home -> Web/GUI Usability -> Why Windows Sucks

Why Windows Sucks (for Me) - Poor Usability of Microsoft Windows

Introduction

This is a random listing of poorly designed or annoying things I've run into in various versions of Microsoft Windows.

Yes, I know this list should be thousands of times longer, but I'm primarily just collecting the things I have encountered--and I've just begun.

Contents

Expandable Tree Lines Removed
Lower-Contrast Icons (Slower to Recognize)
Smooth Scrolling Isn't
Internet Explorer Help Always on Top
XP Windows Explorer No Longer Shows MB Selected
File Search: Can't Type Directory Name
Can't Avoid Searching in Zip Files
File Search in Zip Files Doesn't Show Zip File Pathname
Zip File Location Not Shown Before Internal Pathname
Can't Change Shortcut Tab Items While Target File Doesn't Exist
New Windows Explorer Windows Very Large
Many Settings Windows Not Resizable
Search "Look In" Box Doesn't Show Pathname
Can't Search Multiple Directories
"Save As" Goes to My Documents Instead of Original Location

Expandable Tree Lines Removed

In the tree view in IE's Organize Favorites window, the vertical lines that provided visual alignment are now gone. When you have several nested items open and scroll up and down, it's much harder to tell which folders are at the same level.


Lower-Contrast Icons (Slower to Recognize)

Research has shown that photographs of objects take the longest to recognize, and simple, schematic symbols are the quickest to recognize. So what did Microsoft do for Windows XP? They dropped the simple, schematic icons from before and replaced them with lower-contrast icons.

Additionally, in the various folder icons, the front of the folder is transparent. How was that supposed to be more recognizable?


Smooth Scrolling Isn't

Supposed smooth scrolling isn't smooth. In fact, usually, it's jumpier and harder to follow with your eyes than regular jump scrolling.


Internet Explorer Help Always on Top

Internet Explorer's help window is always on top of other Internet Explorer windows, with no apparent way to turn it off. (XP)


XP Windows Explorer No Longer Shows MB Selected

In Windows XP, Window Explorer (in "open" mode) no longer shows the aggregate size of selected files. TBW:


File Search: Can't Type Directory Name

In Windows WP, in the file search window, you can't just type in a directory name.


Can't Avoid Searching in Zip Files

In Windows XP, the file search function now searches files within Zip files. However, there's no option to disable that new behavior.


File Search in Zip Files Doesn't Show Zip File Pathname

In Windows XP, the file search function now searches files within Zip files. However, it shows only the parent directory pathname within the Zip file, instead of also showing the full pathname of the Zip file itself. TBW:


Zip File Location Not Shown Before Internal Pathname

In a Windows Explorer window for a directory with a Zip file, the window's address field doesn't show the pathname of the Zip file before the directory pathname within the Zip file. (XP)


Can't Change Shortcut Tab Items While Target File Doesn't Exist

If you have a shortcut whose target file doesn't currently exist, when you open the shortcut properties windows, you can't even switch to other tabs to view the current settings. (XP?)


New Windows Explorer Windows Very Large

In Windows XP, all new Windows Explorer windows (and least in "open" mode), are exceedingly large. There doesn't seem to be any way to change the default size (e.g., they don't take the size of the last window you re-sized). TBW:


Many Settings Windows Not Resizable

Many settings dialog windows are not resizable, for example:


Search "Look In" Box Doesn't Show Pathname

In the file search window, the "look in" box doesn't show the full pathname you have selected.


Can't Search Multiple Directories

In the file search window, you can't select multiple directories (folders) under which to search. If in a regular folder window you select multiple folders and then select the Search menu command, you get multiple search windows; you have to repeat your search once for each selected folder.


"Save As" Goes to My Documents Instead of Original Location

The "Save As" command defaults to the My Documents directory (folder) instead of to the directory from which the current document was loaded. For example, to open a document and save a modified version near the original version, you have to navigate from the My Documents directory back to wherever the document was located.